From our correspondent in Singapore
In an email today to the Straits Times, Rohingya community leaders today expressed concern that genocide against the Rohingya is 'not helpful' to the Rohingya.
The comments come in response to independent analysts who have worked for governments, the United Nations and several international organisations with political agendas in Burma, who have expressed concern about people expressing concern about possible genocide against the Rohingya.
The analysts, with no legal experience and qualifications, described a legal analysis by respected organisations specialising in international law and made up of experts in international law as ‘incendiary rhetoric’ and called instead for an ‘accurate diagnosis’. They instead used the well-known accepted legally defined terms of the situation of the Rohingya being ‘extreme discrimination’ and ‘heavily marginalised’, which doesn’t sound nearly as bad and certainly won’t upset the Burmese government as much.
Another former UN official, fresh from a glorious success working on the peace process and who doesn’t sound at all bitter, argued that calling genocide, genocide makes it harder to stop genocide. He also said that the reports that genocide may be taking place, which have been widely reported around the world, were ‘distracting attention’ from broader issues.
Showing posts with label Burma. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Burma. Show all posts
Monday, November 2, 2015
Tuesday, September 15, 2015
Keep hate speech and violence on the streets, not on Facebook, says Burma President
From our correspondent in Nay Pyi Daw
The Office of President Thein Sein has pledged to work with Facebook to ban accounts spreading hate speech in the run up to nationwide elections on November the 8th.
Presidential spokesperson Zaw Htay said the government will use draconian legal powers to apply their interpretation of Facebook community standards.
Amongst the banned activities on Facebook are: threats, intimidation, hateful or disturbing speech, releasing personal information, infringing copyrights, and inciting violence.
“When Myanmar citizens use Facebook they should not be using threats, intimidation, hateful or disturbing speech, or inciting violence. That’s the government’s job,” said Zaw Htay.
The President is reportedly concerned that momentum in promoting hate against religious and ethnic minorities, which has increased dramatically since Thein Sein became President, could be lost if confined to social media sites such as Facebook.
“We haven’t driven hundreds of thousands of Bengali’s out of Myanmar by posting rude Facebook messages,” a Presidential advisor told Burma Tha Din off the record. “We need violence on the streets. If we close the accounts of people spreading hate speech they will be forced onto the streets to spread the word, which is much more effective, as most people in Burma still don’t have internet access.”
The advisor said the proposals were a win win for the President, as he would receive praise from the international community for taking action on hate speech, whilst at the same time as promoting and using hate speech on the streets to counter the popularity of the NLD.
Ma Ba Tha, the government’s official hate speech organisation, also welcomed the move. Wirathu, described by President Thein Sein as a son of Buddha, told Burma Tha Din: “Facebook can be a useful tool, but with so many parts of Burma without internet or good communication, we find preaching hate speech on the ground with the people is the best way to spread the word about the dangers of the Saudi Arabian funded NLD turning Myanmar into a Caliphate. In any case, people keep hacking my accounts.”
Explaining the thinking of the President further, the advisor told Burma Tha Din: “Look at the Tatmadaw, they are making a practical difference on the ground, raping ethnic women, bombing the Kachin, slaughtering farmers in Kokang areas. Our party, the USDP, and the NLD, have banned Muslims from being MP candidates. Ma Ba Tha is preaching hate in every township across Burma, and even in meetings Parliament. And we have passed four anti-Muslim laws in just a few months. This is why the priority is to take action to stop hate speech on the Facebook social media site.”
Burma Tha Din is now on Twitter!: @BurmaThaDin
Labels:
Burma,
Myanmar,
nationalism,
Nazi,
NLD,
political prisoners Kachin,
Rohingya,
Thein Sein
Monday, September 7, 2015
Muslim detectors to be installed at polling stations
From our correspondent in Nay Pyi Daw
Burma Tha Din has uncovered plans by the Union Election Commission (UEC) to install Muslim detectors, similar to airport style metal detectors, at entrances to polling stations for election due on November 8th.
Speaking on condition of anonymity, a UEC official confirmed the plans but said they were not yet ready to formally announce them.
"What else can we do”, asked the official "First we took away the Bingli's right to vote, then rejected their candidates for MPs. The USDP and NLD rejected candidates who are Muslim, and we rejected so many candidates from the Muslim party that their party will now be banned as they can't meet minimum candidate numbers. But these bloody Muslims can't take a hint, and it is learned that many Muslims are still planning to vote."
Questioned about whether there is any way a scanner can detect someone’s religion, the official admitted he also privately had doubts, but said that a consortium of Burmese business men, rumoured to include Tay Za, had promised they had the technology and could offer a very good price.
“Even with the discount we don’t have the funding to install this technology at every polling station, so we are reaching out to international donors for assistance. Sweden, the UK and several other countries helped fund the census which excluded the Rohingya, and as the election will also exclude the Rohingya, we are hoping they will fund this as well. And we can count on the United Nations agencies in Myanmar, who always agree to everything we ask without making a fuss.”
Ma Ba Tha leader, The Venerable U Goebbels, speaking from his private jet en-route from meetings in Nay Pyi Daw, welcomed the proposed move, telling Burma Tha Din; “President Thein Sein truly is a son of Buddha. This is a very cool idea. It’s definitely a good excuse to throw another party!”
Canvassing public opinion on the move, Burma Tha Din found widespread support, with one shopkeeper telling our correspondent; “I totally agree with this, no matter what it costs we must do it. I can’t tell you how worried I have been that I’ll wake up on November 9th to find myself living in a Caliphate and my daughters married to men with beards.”
Burma Tha Din asked an NLD spokesperson for comment but he just gave us the phone number for the local Ma Ba Tha office, muttered something about cutting out the middle man, all these years of sacrifice for what, and then informed us of his resignation.
As the European Union has been a staunch supporter of the election process and is sending election monitors, Burma Tha Din asked for their reaction. However, we were told that the European Union had been unable to reach consensus on a statement as several European Union countries were very interested in purchasing the detectors themselves.
Labels:
Aung San Suu Kyi,
Burma,
Election,
Myanmar,
nationalism,
Nazi
Tuesday, November 25, 2014
National League for Democracy will soon have its first policy
By our correspondent in Yangon
Burma Tha Din can exclusively reveal today that the National League for Democracy (NLD) will soon have its first policy.
A senior leader at the NLD headquarters in Rangoon told Burma Tha Din on condition of anonymity; "I can't tell you what it is or even which area it will be, but someone from the HQ who was taking post and other documents to The Lady's house in Naypyidaw was using the restroom and overheard through the door people in the office mention something about a policy.”
Speculation has been growing that the NLD will announce at least one policy ahead of key national elections expected in late November next year.
Earlier this year the NLD held its first national conference in decades, and some observers had expressed hope that this conference would discuss policy, but in the event no policy matters were put on the agenda, only NLD organisational issues. The establishment of NLD committees on some issues, such as education, also led to fevered speculation about the NLD having specific policies, but so far none have materialized.
NLD officials gave mixed responses to our correspondent when asked about the lack of policies. One NLD leader stated that there is no need for the NLD to have any policies as they are not in government, and they will make some when they get into government. Another said that people will vote NLD anyway, so they don’t need any. Why take the risk of upsetting anyone?
However, another NLD leader said that they may indeed have policies, but simply haven’t been told about them. “Dr Tin Mar Aung won’t let us see The Lady, so we have no idea what she is agreeing in all the meetings that she has with the United Nations and foreign visitors. When Dr Tin Mar Aung decides the time is right, she will let the people she likes know what the correct policy is.”
Aung San Suu Kyi and her policy team meet with the Indian Prime Minister and his policy team earlier this month
Burma Tha Din can exclusively reveal today that the National League for Democracy (NLD) will soon have its first policy.
A senior leader at the NLD headquarters in Rangoon told Burma Tha Din on condition of anonymity; "I can't tell you what it is or even which area it will be, but someone from the HQ who was taking post and other documents to The Lady's house in Naypyidaw was using the restroom and overheard through the door people in the office mention something about a policy.”
Speculation has been growing that the NLD will announce at least one policy ahead of key national elections expected in late November next year.
Earlier this year the NLD held its first national conference in decades, and some observers had expressed hope that this conference would discuss policy, but in the event no policy matters were put on the agenda, only NLD organisational issues. The establishment of NLD committees on some issues, such as education, also led to fevered speculation about the NLD having specific policies, but so far none have materialized.
NLD officials gave mixed responses to our correspondent when asked about the lack of policies. One NLD leader stated that there is no need for the NLD to have any policies as they are not in government, and they will make some when they get into government. Another said that people will vote NLD anyway, so they don’t need any. Why take the risk of upsetting anyone?
However, another NLD leader said that they may indeed have policies, but simply haven’t been told about them. “Dr Tin Mar Aung won’t let us see The Lady, so we have no idea what she is agreeing in all the meetings that she has with the United Nations and foreign visitors. When Dr Tin Mar Aung decides the time is right, she will let the people she likes know what the correct policy is.”
Aung San Suu Kyi and her policy team meet with the Indian Prime Minister and his policy team earlier this month
Labels:
Aung San Suu Kyi,
Burma,
India,
Myanmar,
NLD
Monday, October 1, 2012
Rohingya’s To Blame for Climate Change - Report
By our correspondent in Cox’s Bizarre
Burma Tha Din Network has obtained a confidential draft of a report on recent violence in Rakhine State, Burma, which links the ethnic Rohingya to global climate change.
The leaking of the report coincides with the Rohingya also being blamed for violence in Bangladesh.
The draft report, prepared for Myanmar’s Border Affairs Ministry by journalists from the Weekly Eleven Media Group, claims that Na Sa Ka agents found evidence in the abandoned homes of Rohingya linking them with a conspiracy to create global climate change.
Despite the extensive 1,982 page report going on to provide great detail on the ‘conspiracy’, no evidence is cited to back the claims. The reports devotes several chapters to reasons why the ‘Bengali’s’ want to ‘invade’ Burma. It claims the ‘Bangali’s’ were attracted to move from Bangladesh to Burma by Burma’s lower GDP, lower access to health services (33% of population in Burma had access compared to 45% in Bangladesh), lower access to safe water (27% Burma, 46% Bangladesh, and higher levels of children stunted by malnutrition (75% Burma, 59% Bangladesh). (Statistics all date from 1980s).
The ‘illegal Bengali’s’ were also attracted to move to Burma by Burma’s terrible record on human rights and lack of democracy, and by the discrimination they constantly faced. Living in Burma also enabled them to be closer to the mass graves where their ancestors are buried. The report states that what it calls ‘illegal Bengali Muslim immigrants’ first hatched a new conspiracy to continue their takeover of Rakhine State and then the whole of Burma as long ago as 1990. They were inspired by the first report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which speculated that over the following century it was possible that 60 percent of Bangladesh could be flooded by rising sea levels. The report claims: ‘The Bengali’s hatched a conspiracy to make climate change worse, calculating that if Bangladesh was flooded it would be impossible for them to be sent back there.’ The report doesn’t specify how the Rohingya carried out this plot, despite claiming it was successful.
The report also speculates on Rohingya involvement in several other global conspiracies, including the sinking of the Costa Concordia Cruise ship off the coast of Italy in July this year, recent earthquakes in New Zealand, and the alleged kidnapping of Elvis, believed to be being held in a safe house near Sittwe. Officials from the Ministry of Border Affairs were not available for comment owing to attending a conference on peacebuilding at the luxury Regina Hotel and Golf Course in eastern Shan State.
Burma Tha Din Network has obtained a confidential draft of a report on recent violence in Rakhine State, Burma, which links the ethnic Rohingya to global climate change.
The leaking of the report coincides with the Rohingya also being blamed for violence in Bangladesh.
The draft report, prepared for Myanmar’s Border Affairs Ministry by journalists from the Weekly Eleven Media Group, claims that Na Sa Ka agents found evidence in the abandoned homes of Rohingya linking them with a conspiracy to create global climate change.
Despite the extensive 1,982 page report going on to provide great detail on the ‘conspiracy’, no evidence is cited to back the claims. The reports devotes several chapters to reasons why the ‘Bengali’s’ want to ‘invade’ Burma. It claims the ‘Bangali’s’ were attracted to move from Bangladesh to Burma by Burma’s lower GDP, lower access to health services (33% of population in Burma had access compared to 45% in Bangladesh), lower access to safe water (27% Burma, 46% Bangladesh, and higher levels of children stunted by malnutrition (75% Burma, 59% Bangladesh). (Statistics all date from 1980s).
The ‘illegal Bengali’s’ were also attracted to move to Burma by Burma’s terrible record on human rights and lack of democracy, and by the discrimination they constantly faced. Living in Burma also enabled them to be closer to the mass graves where their ancestors are buried. The report states that what it calls ‘illegal Bengali Muslim immigrants’ first hatched a new conspiracy to continue their takeover of Rakhine State and then the whole of Burma as long ago as 1990. They were inspired by the first report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which speculated that over the following century it was possible that 60 percent of Bangladesh could be flooded by rising sea levels. The report claims: ‘The Bengali’s hatched a conspiracy to make climate change worse, calculating that if Bangladesh was flooded it would be impossible for them to be sent back there.’ The report doesn’t specify how the Rohingya carried out this plot, despite claiming it was successful.
The report also speculates on Rohingya involvement in several other global conspiracies, including the sinking of the Costa Concordia Cruise ship off the coast of Italy in July this year, recent earthquakes in New Zealand, and the alleged kidnapping of Elvis, believed to be being held in a safe house near Sittwe. Officials from the Ministry of Border Affairs were not available for comment owing to attending a conference on peacebuilding at the luxury Regina Hotel and Golf Course in eastern Shan State.
Labels:
Burma,
Climate Change,
Elvis.,
Rohingya
Location:
R820, Bangladesh
Saturday, June 11, 2011
Burma Tha Din Network is today publishing this leaked extract from a Fire Service report on what took place at a Foreign Ministry before it was destroyed by fire. As will become clear when you read this, the diplomat was a Burma Desk Officer. To protect our sources we cannot name which country he was from.
FIRE SERVICE - CAUSE OF FIRE REPORT XXXXX SERVICE. XXX XXXXXXX
NGO worker arrives at Foreign Ministry. IS met at reception and taken to the diplomats office for the meeeting.
While passing kitchen on way to meeting in office.
NGO Visitor: Sorry, but there are bare electric cables next to that leaking water cooler. Is it safe?
Diplomat: well obviously it isn’t ideal, and we are considering calling an electrician. Ah here, my office is the next room.
5 minutes later:
NGO Visitor: I can smell smoke, can you smell anything?
Diplomat: No
NGO Visitor: are you sure you can’t smell anything?
Diplomat: Yes. Now as I was saying...
Another 5 minutes have passed:
NGO Visitor: I really can smell smoke quite strongly. I think you should check it out.
Diplomat: There may be a very slight smell, but I am sure there is nothing to worry about. I do appreciate hearing your opinion though.
Another 3 minutes pass
NGO Visitor: I am getting really worried, I can see smoke coming through the door there.
Diplomat: Hmmm yes, well obviously I am concerned, but I am sure it’s nothing to worry about.
NGO Visitor: Nothing to worry about! There is a fire!
Diplomat: Ah now, let’s not be too hasty, we haven’t actually seen any flames.
NGO Visitor: What? You don’t need to see flames to know there is a fire? It’s obvious. Those cables in the kitchen must have caught fire.
Diplomat: We don’t have all the facts, there may be a fire, but we don’t know for sure.
NGO Visitor: Well go and have a look!
Diplomat: It isn’t that easy, there are contractors hired to take care of communal areas, I am really only able to make decisions about what happens in my own office.
NGO Visitor: This is crazy, call the fire brigade!
Diplomat: That is quite a dramatic proposal, I am not sure that now is the right time for that.
NGO Visitor: So what are you going to do? We are in real danger!
Diplomat: Now now. Let’s not get emotional. I’ll speak to some colleagues, sound them out, and see what the consensus is on what should be done.
NGO Visitor: You are going to sit there and talk while we might burn to death. It’s getting hard to breathe there is so much smoke! You need to sound the alarm, and call the fire service!
Diplomat: I am just going to make some calls. I appreciate this is an emotional issue must we must try to keep calm and be rational and realistic.
Five more minutes pass, the room is filling with smoke and they have to sit on the floor to avoid it.
NGO Visitor: Well!?
Diplomat: Well it is clear that there is a problem, but calling the fire brigade it not as easy as it sounds, the phone call might not get through properly, so a first step might be to try a fire extinguisher.
NGO Visitor: It is too late for that! Look, there are flames at the door now, and the fire extinguishers are in the corridor. We can’t get to them.
Diplomat: Yes, that is disappointing. We are going to have to monitor this situation very carefully.
NGO Visitor: Monitor! You need to act. Set off the fire alarm, call the damn fire service!
Diplomat: Let’s be realistic about what we are able to do. Now look, there is a glass of water on the desk closest to the door. Once the fire reaches that it may put the fire out. Let’s wait and see.
NGO Visitor: A glass of water can’t possibly put out a fire that big. If you won’t sound the alarm I will. FIRE! FIRE!
Fire starts to creep into the office. The glass of water shatters in the heat, and keeps advancing.
Diplomat: I do agree that it this is a very serious situation, which obviously couldn’t have been anticipated.(Pulls lever of fire alarm on the wall)
NGO Visitor: At last, how long before the fire service get here?
Diplomat: Ah, just because I have sounded the fire alarm, it doesn’t necessarily follow that the fire service will come.
NGO Visitor: I don’t believe this, I’m using my mobile to call for help.
Diplomat: Of course if you think that is wise, but sometimes one just has to accept that only so much can be done, and we did everything we could.
NGO Visitor: You did not! You could have prevented this!
Diplomat: I really don’t think that is fair. There are offices, albeit smaller ones, closer to the kitchen than mine, and really they should have done something about this.
NGO Visitor: We are trapped now, we are going to die!
Diplomat: Well it’s possible, I must concede, but let’s wait and see. Our development ministry is next door, and I am sure that when the fire dies down, they’ll help clean up the mess.
NGO Visitor: That’ll be too late for us! We are going to die, and it is your fault for not doing anything to prevent this.
Diplomat: I wouldn’t look at it that way. I did talk to others about the situation, and did sound the alarm, I have done everything possible, given the difficulties we faced.
FIRE SERVICE XXXXXXX - NO FURTHER ACTION.
FIRE SERVICE - CAUSE OF FIRE REPORT XXXXX SERVICE. XXX XXXXXXX
NGO worker arrives at Foreign Ministry. IS met at reception and taken to the diplomats office for the meeeting.
While passing kitchen on way to meeting in office.
NGO Visitor: Sorry, but there are bare electric cables next to that leaking water cooler. Is it safe?
Diplomat: well obviously it isn’t ideal, and we are considering calling an electrician. Ah here, my office is the next room.
5 minutes later:
NGO Visitor: I can smell smoke, can you smell anything?
Diplomat: No
NGO Visitor: are you sure you can’t smell anything?
Diplomat: Yes. Now as I was saying...
Another 5 minutes have passed:
NGO Visitor: I really can smell smoke quite strongly. I think you should check it out.
Diplomat: There may be a very slight smell, but I am sure there is nothing to worry about. I do appreciate hearing your opinion though.
Another 3 minutes pass
NGO Visitor: I am getting really worried, I can see smoke coming through the door there.
Diplomat: Hmmm yes, well obviously I am concerned, but I am sure it’s nothing to worry about.
NGO Visitor: Nothing to worry about! There is a fire!
Diplomat: Ah now, let’s not be too hasty, we haven’t actually seen any flames.
NGO Visitor: What? You don’t need to see flames to know there is a fire? It’s obvious. Those cables in the kitchen must have caught fire.
Diplomat: We don’t have all the facts, there may be a fire, but we don’t know for sure.
NGO Visitor: Well go and have a look!
Diplomat: It isn’t that easy, there are contractors hired to take care of communal areas, I am really only able to make decisions about what happens in my own office.
NGO Visitor: This is crazy, call the fire brigade!
Diplomat: That is quite a dramatic proposal, I am not sure that now is the right time for that.
NGO Visitor: So what are you going to do? We are in real danger!
Diplomat: Now now. Let’s not get emotional. I’ll speak to some colleagues, sound them out, and see what the consensus is on what should be done.
NGO Visitor: You are going to sit there and talk while we might burn to death. It’s getting hard to breathe there is so much smoke! You need to sound the alarm, and call the fire service!
Diplomat: I am just going to make some calls. I appreciate this is an emotional issue must we must try to keep calm and be rational and realistic.
Five more minutes pass, the room is filling with smoke and they have to sit on the floor to avoid it.
NGO Visitor: Well!?
Diplomat: Well it is clear that there is a problem, but calling the fire brigade it not as easy as it sounds, the phone call might not get through properly, so a first step might be to try a fire extinguisher.
NGO Visitor: It is too late for that! Look, there are flames at the door now, and the fire extinguishers are in the corridor. We can’t get to them.
Diplomat: Yes, that is disappointing. We are going to have to monitor this situation very carefully.
NGO Visitor: Monitor! You need to act. Set off the fire alarm, call the damn fire service!
Diplomat: Let’s be realistic about what we are able to do. Now look, there is a glass of water on the desk closest to the door. Once the fire reaches that it may put the fire out. Let’s wait and see.
NGO Visitor: A glass of water can’t possibly put out a fire that big. If you won’t sound the alarm I will. FIRE! FIRE!
Fire starts to creep into the office. The glass of water shatters in the heat, and keeps advancing.
Diplomat: I do agree that it this is a very serious situation, which obviously couldn’t have been anticipated.(Pulls lever of fire alarm on the wall)
NGO Visitor: At last, how long before the fire service get here?
Diplomat: Ah, just because I have sounded the fire alarm, it doesn’t necessarily follow that the fire service will come.
NGO Visitor: I don’t believe this, I’m using my mobile to call for help.
Diplomat: Of course if you think that is wise, but sometimes one just has to accept that only so much can be done, and we did everything we could.
NGO Visitor: You did not! You could have prevented this!
Diplomat: I really don’t think that is fair. There are offices, albeit smaller ones, closer to the kitchen than mine, and really they should have done something about this.
NGO Visitor: We are trapped now, we are going to die!
Diplomat: Well it’s possible, I must concede, but let’s wait and see. Our development ministry is next door, and I am sure that when the fire dies down, they’ll help clean up the mess.
NGO Visitor: That’ll be too late for us! We are going to die, and it is your fault for not doing anything to prevent this.
Diplomat: I wouldn’t look at it that way. I did talk to others about the situation, and did sound the alarm, I have done everything possible, given the difficulties we faced.
FIRE SERVICE XXXXXXX - NO FURTHER ACTION.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
